Legal Challenges in Suing the Military for Medical Malpractice Abroad – For the Military – Khawam Ripka LLP
BREAKING NEWS: You can now file a claim for sexual assault while on active duty in the military, as per the recent 9th Circuit Court decision. Call us today for your free consultation!
BREAKING NEWS: You can now file a claim for sexual assault while on active duty in the military, as per the recent 9th Circuit Court decision. Call us today for your free consultation!

Legal Challenges in Suing the Military for Medical Malpractice Abroad

Medical malpractice can be devastating under any circumstances, but when it occurs within the military, particularly overseas, pursuing justice can be even more complex. Military service members and their families often face unique hurdles when trying to seek compensation for medical negligence abroad. This blog explores the legal challenges associated with suing the military for medical malpractice overseas, offers insights into existing legal frameworks, and provides actionable steps for those affected.

Understanding Medical Malpractice in a Military Context

Medical malpractice refers to instances where a healthcare provider deviates from the standard of care, resulting in harm to a patient. In a military context, malpractice cases often arise in military treatment facilities (MTFs) or during deployments, where access to civilian legal systems can be limited. Unlike civilian cases, suing for military medical malpractice involves navigating specific legal doctrines, such as the Feres Doctrine, which can complicate the process.

Key Legal Challenges in Suing the Military for Medical Malpractice Abroad

1. The Feres Doctrine

The most significant obstacle in suing the military is the Feres Doctrine, established by the Supreme Court in 1950. This legal principle bars active-duty service members from suing the federal government for injuries “incident to service.” While the doctrine aims to maintain military discipline and efficiency, it has been widely criticized for denying service members access to justice, even in clear cases of medical negligence.

Impact Abroad:
When medical malpractice occurs at an overseas military base or during deployment, the Feres Doctrine applies just as it does domestically. This makes it nearly impossible for active-duty members to sue, regardless of the severity of their injuries or the circumstances of the malpractice.

2. Limited Jurisdiction in Foreign Courts

Military medical facilities abroad often operate under Status of Forces Agreements (SOFAs) between the U.S. and host countries. These agreements typically grant the U.S. military legal jurisdiction over its personnel and operations, shielding it from lawsuits in foreign courts.

Implications for Families:
While the Feres Doctrine prevents active-duty members from suing, dependents and retirees may still pursue claims in some cases. However, SOFAs often limit their ability to file lawsuits in the host country, forcing them to rely on U.S.-based legal remedies.

3. Sovereign Immunity and Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA)

Under the principle of sovereign immunity, the federal government is generally immune from lawsuits unless it consents to be sued. The Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) provides a limited waiver of this immunity, allowing individuals to sue the government for negligence under certain conditions.

Challenges with the FTCA:

  • Geographic Limitations: The FTCA typically applies only to incidents occurring on U.S. soil. Overseas claims often fall outside its jurisdiction.
  • Administrative Hurdles: Before filing a lawsuit, claimants must exhaust administrative remedies by submitting a claim to the appropriate federal agency. This process can be time-consuming and often results in denial.

4. Time Limitations

Strict time limits, known as statutes of limitations, can further complicate military malpractice claims. Under the FTCA, claimants generally have two years from the date of the malpractice to file a claim. For incidents occurring abroad, delays in gathering evidence or understanding legal options can lead to missed deadlines.

Special Considerations:
Timeframes may vary depending on whether the claimant is an active-duty member, dependent, or retiree. Consulting with a knowledgeable attorney early in the process is crucial to avoid losing the right to sue.

5. Difficulty Accessing Evidence

In medical malpractice cases, proving negligence requires access to medical records, expert opinions, and witness testimony. When the malpractice occurs overseas, obtaining these critical pieces of evidence can be particularly challenging. Language barriers, classified information, and bureaucratic red tape often hinder the evidence-gathering process.

Legal Pathways and Recent Developments

The Richard Stayskal Military Medical Accountability Act

Passed as part of the 2020 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), the Richard Stayskal Military Medical Accountability Act offers a new pathway for active-duty service members to seek compensation for medical malpractice. Named after a Green Beret who fought for accountability after being misdiagnosed with cancer, this law allows active-duty personnel to file claims with the Department of Defense (DoD) for injuries caused by medical negligence.

Limitations:

  • The Act does not allow for lawsuits in federal court; claims are handled administratively by the DoD.
  • Compensation caps and other restrictions may limit recovery amounts.

Claims by Dependents and Retirees

While active-duty members are barred from suing under the Feres Doctrine, dependents and retirees can often file malpractice claims under the FTCA. However, pursuing these claims requires careful navigation of both U.S. and international legal systems, especially when incidents occur overseas.

How to Pursue a Military Medical Malpractice Claim

1. Understand Your Legal Standing

Determining your eligibility to file a claim is the first step. Active-duty members may need to explore options under the Stayskal Act, while dependents and retirees can investigate FTCA claims.

2. Document Everything

Collect and preserve all relevant medical records, correspondence, and evidence related to the malpractice. If the incident occurred overseas, ensure you obtain translations of any non-English documents.

3. File an Administrative Claim

For FTCA and Stayskal Act cases, the process begins with filing an administrative claim with the appropriate federal agency. Be prepared to include:

  • A detailed description of the incident
  • The harm caused
  • The compensation amount sought

4. Consult a Military Medical Malpractice Attorney

Given the complexity of these cases, legal representation is essential. An experienced attorney can help navigate the unique challenges of suing the military and ensure all procedural requirements are met.

Conclusion:

Suing the military for medical malpractice abroad is a daunting process, fraught with legal hurdles and systemic challenges. However, recent developments like the Richard Stayskal Act provide hope for increased accountability. Dependents, retirees, and even active-duty members now have more avenues to seek justice than ever before.

If you or a loved one has experienced medical malpractice in a military context, understanding your legal options is crucial. At Khawam Ripka LLP, we specialize in military medical malpractice cases, helping clients navigate these complex claims with compassion and expertise.

Don’t let medical malpractice go unaddressed. Contact us today for a consultation and let us help you fight for the justice and compensation you deserve. Visit Khawam  Ripka LLP to get started.

Follow Us

Linkedin Facebook-f Instagram Twitter

More Post

Here at Khawam Ripka, we are passionate about helping heroes in the military get the attention and financial compensation they, and their families, deserve.

If you or someone you love has been a victim of military medical malpractice, we would be honored to represent them and their family in their claim.

CONTACT US

Watch how Attorney Natalie Khawam fought for a decorated Green Beret

Free Case Review

Share your experience and we will call you
If you were Active-duty within the last 2 years, we can help.

Privacy Policy and Terms & Conditions

Your privacy is important to Khawam Ripka, LLP and its affiliated companies (hereinafter collectively referred to as “we,” “us,” “our” or “Khawam Ripka, LLP”). Because your privacy is our concern, we have developed this Privacy Policy to inform you about Khawam Ripka, LLP’s privacy practices. This Privacy Policy covers how we collect, use, disclose, transfer, and store your information. The examples in this Privacy Policy are illustrative only and are not intended to be exhaustive.

INFORMATION COLLECTED

We use the term “Personal Information” to mean any information that could reasonably be used to identify you, including your name, address, telephone number(s), driver’s license number, occupation, date of birth, social security number, personal or business tax identification numbers, legal information (such as judgment, liens, bankruptcies, etc.), credit history, and medical information (such as your health status and treatment history). The information we obtain depends on the context of your interactions with us. We may obtain such information directly from you on our website (the “Site”) or by telephone, and/or from applications, contracts, documents and forms you complete or sign. We may obtain additional information about you or, with your authorization, about others who may have an interest in your insurance or annuity policy, from your insurance or annuity company, insurance producer, health care providers, creditors, credit reporting agencies, and from your representatives or advisors. We may also obtain information about you from public records and, with your authorization, from other persons.

We use the term “Anonymous Information” to mean any information that does not identify you, and may include, for example, aggregated demographic information and statistical information concerning how you and other visitors use our website (the “Site”).

USE OF PERSONAL INFORMATION

We use the Personal Information you provide for purposes of the transactions or information that you request. As permitted by law, or as authorized by you, we may share your Personal Information with affiliated and non-affiliated companies that provide services related to information or transactions you request, under the following additional circumstances: (i) for us to establish or exercise our legal rights or to defend against legal claims; (ii) in connection with a proposed or actual sale, merger, transfer, exchange or consolidation of Khawam Ripka, LLP, an affiliated company or any portion thereof; (iii) to secure or obtain services and/or advice from our attorneys, accountants and auditors; and (iv) to permit our affiliates to contact you about products or services. We may also disclose your Personal Information to others for other purposes, with your authorization or otherwise as required or permitted by law.

Maintaining the accuracy of your information is a shared responsibility. We maintain the integrity of the information you provide us and will update your records when you notify us of a change. Please contact us at the address or phone number listed below when information concerning you changes.

USE OF ANONYMOUS INFORMATION

We may share Anonymous Information with our partners and resources.

FORMER CONTACTS OR INQUIRIES

We treat information obtained from past contacts and inquiries in the same manner we treat information that we obtain through current or future contacts or inquiries.

CONFIDENTIALITY AND SECURITY

We restrict access to your Personal Information to our employees who need this information in connection with your current or future transaction(s) or to provide you information that you may request from us. We maintain electronic, procedural, and physical safeguards to guard your nonpublic information. We take precautions to protect your information, but remember that no method of transmission over the Internet, or method of electronic storage, is 100% secure. While the computers/servers in which we store your Personal Information are kept in a secure environment, we cannot guarantee absolute security.

UPDATES TO OUR PRIVACY POLICY

We reserve the right to change this privacy policy at any time. If our information practices change, we will post the changed policy to our website. These privacy principles do not constitute a contract, create legal rights, or supersede any preexisting agreements with clients.

“COOKIES”

We use “cookies” on this site. A cookie is a piece of data stored on a site visitor’s hard drive to help us improve your access to our site and identify repeat visitors to our site. For instance, when we use a cookie to identify you, you would not have to log in a password more than once, thereby saving time while on our site. Cookies can also enable us to track and target the interests of our users to enhance the experience on our site. Usage of a cookie is in no way linked to any personally identifiable information on our site. Note that your browser settings may allow you to automatically transmit a “Do Not Track” signal to websites and online services you visit. There is no consensus among industry participants as to what “Do Not Track” means in this context. Like many websites, Khawam Ripka, LLP currently does not alter its practices when it receives a “Do Not Track” signal from a visitor’s browser.

LINKING

Our Site may contain links to other affiliated websites. Because we do not control the content of websites linking to or from our Site, we are not responsible nor can we make representations regarding the content of those websites or their individual privacy policies. We encourage you to read the privacy policies of any website that links to or from our Site that collects personally identifiable information.